I pooled all the different rankings together into one:

Overall
1	Oscar Taveras	1.000
2	Shelby Miller	2.100
3	Carlos Martinez	3.600
4	Trevor Rosenthal	3.900
5	Michael Wacha	5.000
6	Kolten Wong	5.600
7	Matt Adams	7.300
8	Tyrell Jenkins	8.000
9	Carson Kelly	10.200
10	Anthony Garcia	11.000
11	Stephen Piscotty	12.375
12	Patrick Wisdom	13.833
13	Greg Garcia	14.833
14	Jordan Swagerty	16.000
15	John Gast	16.011
16	James Ramsey	16.743
17	Ryan Jackson	16.889
18	Seth Maness	17.033
19	Charlie Tilson	17.850
20	Starlin Rodriguez	19.000
21	Kevin Siegrist	19.033
22	Pete Kozma	19.100
23	Maikel Cleto	19.500
24	Victor De Leon	21.167
25	Breyvic Valera	21.250
26	Tyler Lyons	22.600
29	C.J. McElroy	23.600
27	Steve Bean	24.000
28	Boone Whiting	24.017
30	Adron Chambers	25.110
31	Eric Fornataro	24.288
32	Sam Freeman	24.333
33	Eduardo Sanchez	26.000
34	Tim Cooney	29.400
35	Robert Stock	30.000
36	Michael Blazek	30.650
37	Seth Blair	31.333
38	Dixon Llorens	31.500
39	Scott Gorgen	33.150
40	Mike O'Neill	33.667
41	Lee Stoppelman	35.000
42	Adam Ehrlich	35.450
43	Colin Walsh	35.583
44	Jorge Rondon	36.667
45	Audry Perez	37.000
46	Keith Butler	37.667
47	Alex Mejia	39.000
48	Silfredo Garcia	42.333

Some notes:

I gave some players 0.1 votes so there wasn't any ties.  I gave the players rep'd by the birdhouse here the higher vote score. For instance, Gast and Swagerty were both a 16.0, but I gave Gast an 18.1 from our vote, since we had Swagerty higher.

Some players, such as Robert Stock, were highly rated on just, in Stock's case, Mayo's list, which had him at #14.  So the #14 is just averaged with the #46 from here for a #30 overall ranking, despite no other service putting him in the rankings.

Conversely, Anthony Garcia was not included in BA's top 30, meaning he is likely somewhere after #30, but since he wasn't listed, I didn't include a post-30 number for him, keeping his overall score in the low-teens. Interestingly, he was ranked in the top 10 on 5 lists and not at all on 4 others.

I included Domeboys pooled ranking and the Birdhouse rankings despite it already including our Birdhouse ranking. That gives our scores a little more weight in the overall scheme. I did that on purpose as these mean more to me.

I included the following 10 rankings:

Birdhouse (top 50 - our vote)
CN (top 40 - Domeboys, CC, and our vote combined)
Future Redbirds (top 20 - 3 pooled writers from there)
Fangraphs (top 15 - Marc Hulet)
Minor League Ball (top 20 - John Sickels)
Gateway RBs (top 30 - phins)
Baseball America (top 31 - Jim Callis)
Baseball Instincts (top 21 - Thomas Belmont)
Baseball Prospectus (top 10 - Jason Parks)
milb.com (top 20 - Jonathan Mayo)

Comparing the Cardinal Nation rankings with the consensus determined by PadsFS, the following differences of more than 3 spots are from where we ranked higher to where we ranked lower.

O'Neill - +8
Ehrlich - +8
Freeman - +8
A Perez - +7
Walsh - +7
Blair - +7
Sanchez - +7
Chambers - +7
Valera - +6
Butler - +6
Llorens - +5
Maness - +4
Fornatero - +4
Gast - -5
Cleto - -5
Cooney - -5
Wisdom - -6
Kozma - -7
DeLeon - -13

Since PadsFS listed 48 players there are several players on his list that did not make the Cardinal Nation top 40. So I compared his list to the Community rankings.

Differences were
Bean - -12 (Community ranked lower)
Stock - -11
Blazek - -12
Stoppelman - +6
Rondon - -1
Mejia - +8
S. Garcia - +6
Gorgon - -11