Free Trial Ad
Why Subscribe?
  • Player/Prospect News
  • Exclusive Insider Info
  • Members-Only Forums
  • Exclusive Videos
  • Subscribe Now!
Inbox
Reply to TopicPost New Topic
  Page of 2  Next >

What's worse?

  • Lucci33
  • Member
  • 2466 posts this site

Posted: 10/01/2012 10:15 PM

What's worse? 


Winning the last two games to finish 1 under .500  OR losing one or two of them?
Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/02/2012 6:04 AM

Re: What's worse? 


Its poetic.  The Pirates will surely win their last 2 games (finally sweeping the Braves).  Their 82nd loss came at the hands of the Reds in the 9th inning - echoing the 9th inning loss of 1972 in Game 5 of the playoffs.

There's more at play here than meets the eye... 

Reply | Quote
  • diener
  • Member
  • 131 posts this site

Posted: 10/02/2012 6:45 AM

Re: What's worse? 


This team still has the chance to be the greatest Pirate team of the last 20 years eclipsing the "great" '99 team that finished 79-83.  Right now they are tied with the '99 wonder team that ended at 78-84.

oh happy day break out the IC light.
Reply | Quote

Posted: 10/02/2012 7:16 AM

RE: What's worse? 


No offense but this board is full of pessimism and always will be. The team is extremely young not one full of players a year away from free agency like the one inherited in 2008 by Huntington.

I can already see how the future complaints will be.

2013 - Pirates win 86 games.
Complaint: We didn't make the playoffs, everyone should be fired

2014 - Pirates win 91 games.
Complaint: Well we made the playoffs but we didn't win and it's because Nutting is cheap

2015 - Pirates win 93 games and make it to the World Series.
Complaint: We still suck because we didn't win

2016 - Pirates win the World Series
Complaint: It still wasn't worth it because we had to watch the Pirates lose over 100 games in 2010

2017 - Pirates win 91 games and lose in the playoffs
Complaint: This team doesn't care about it's fans. They have no interest in trying to win consistently.

2018 - Pirates win 88 games and just miss the playoffs
Complaint: Same old Pirates
Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/02/2012 8:22 AM

Re: What's worse? 


katoy -- you say that as if it is a new thing.

For years now this board has reflected a pronounced dichotomy between your optimism versus the pessimism of most of the rest of us (including me).

Given that the Streak just hit 20, I think the rest of us are ahead of you.  biggrin  J/K

___________

 

  

Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/02/2012 8:31 AM

RE: What's worse? 



katoy2j wrote: No offense but this board is full of pessimism and always will be. The team is extremely young not one full of players a year away from free agency like the one inherited in 2008 by Huntington.

I can already see how the future complaints will be.

2013 - Pirates win 86 games.
Complaint: We didn't make the playoffs, everyone should be fired

2014 - Pirates win 91 games.
Complaint: Well we made the playoffs but we didn't win and it's because Nutting is cheap

2015 - Pirates win 93 games and make it to the World Series.
Complaint: We still suck because we didn't win

2016 - Pirates win the World Series
Complaint: It still wasn't worth it because we had to watch the Pirates lose over 100 games in 2010

2017 - Pirates win 91 games and lose in the playoffs
Complaint: This team doesn't care about it's fans. They have no interest in trying to win consistently.

2018 - Pirates win 88 games and just miss the playoffs
Complaint: Same old Pirates
I know, right?  Its only been 20 years of losing baseball.  Sunny side people, Sunny side.

Hey why didn't Nutting get us that extra bat for the stretch in 2014?

2015 - Yep, I'd rather not go to the World Series than lose in the World Series.

Here's another scenario:

2013 - Pirates win 74 games.
Complaint: We went backwards this year.

2014 - Pirates win 80 games.
Complaint: Good God.  22 years?  Couldn't we just win one of those last six games?

2015 - Pirates win 80 games.
Complaint: Really?  Again? 

2016 - Pirates finish over .500
Complaint: None. Ticker tape parade last 3 days.

2017 - Pirates win 77 games
Complaint: These aren't your 2016 Pirates.

2018 - Pirates win 74 games
Complaint: Same old Pirates
Reply | Quote

Posted: 10/02/2012 9:01 AM

RE: What's worse? 


I think I am generally positive when it comes to the Pirates. I have even supported NH and the "plan".

In saying that, if they achieve what you note below I will swim across the Ohio River in the middle of December.
katoy2j wrote: No offense but this board is full of pessimism and always will be. The team is extremely young not one full of players a year away from free agency like the one inherited in 2008 by Huntington.

I can already see how the future complaints will be.

2013 - Pirates win 86 games.
Complaint: We didn't make the playoffs, everyone should be fired

2014 - Pirates win 91 games.
Complaint: Well we made the playoffs but we didn't win and it's because Nutting is cheap

2015 - Pirates win 93 games and make it to the World Series.
Complaint: We still suck because we didn't win

2016 - Pirates win the World Series
Complaint: It still wasn't worth it because we had to watch the Pirates lose over 100 games in 2010

2017 - Pirates win 91 games and lose in the playoffs
Complaint: This team doesn't care about it's fans. They have no interest in trying to win consistently.

2018 - Pirates win 88 games and just miss the playoffs
Complaint: Same old Pirates
Reply | Quote

Posted: 10/02/2012 9:28 AM

RE: What's worse? 


2015 will be a championship caliber team. I believe it. This team wasn't. We all knew it, but to be 16 games above .500 after 108 and the worst team in baseball for the last 54 is hard to wrap your head around.

2015 should have Heredia, Cole, and Taillon at the top. Cutch, Alvarez, Marte, Bell, Hanson, Polanco, Walker of some combo should be here. I still think Alvarez will be star. If you don't believe, what are you still doing here? Self flagellation?
Reply | Quote

Posted: 10/02/2012 9:47 AM

RE: What's worse? 


Obviously the potential is there.

But so much has to go right that I simply will believe it when I see it.

BAMSTEELERFAN wrote: 2015 will be a championship caliber team. I believe it. This team wasn't. We all knew it, but to be 16 games above .500 after 108 and the worst team in baseball for the last 54 is hard to wrap your head around.

2015 should have Heredia, Cole, and Taillon at the top. Cutch, Alvarez, Marte, Bell, Hanson, Polanco, Walker of some combo should be here. I still think Alvarez will be star. If you don't believe, what are you still doing here? Self flagellation?
Reply | Quote

Posted: 10/02/2012 9:53 AM

RE: What's worse? 


How can you not be optimistic about the Pirates direction though? Go and read nearly every thread the last month and you would swear this team lost 110 games this year. You know what people were saying when the Pirates lost 100 plus games in 2010? That they just wanted a competitive team one that had a chance to win and what not. This years team is one that will finish between 78-80 wins. It has it's top 2 prospects on track to make the team next year that will join a core of players that range in the ages of 24-27. It has no bad long term contracts and the nearest core player is 3 years away from free agency.

This 20 year streak means nothing to me. If we won 82 games or 80 it's irrelevant for me. What does not having a losing season accomplish? Do you think free agents will be lining up to sign with us if we won 82 games? It comes down to money first and foremost but I seriously doubt those extra couple of wins will tilt the decision in either direction. Agents and players are smart. They can see which teams look like they will step forward. The Nationals finished with an 80-81 record. Edwin Jackson chose them over the Pirates as they had Harper ready to step through next year. If a free agent has a choice between Pittsburgh and the Mets or Mariners, most players would pick the Pirates.
Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/02/2012 10:31 AM

Re: What's worse? 


I'll say about the same thing I said last year at this time about next year's team -- I'm very hopeful, but not particularly optimistic.  On their shoestring budget, everything has to go just right -- minor leaguers have to develop, cheap free agents need to overperform, and all of them need to avoid injury.  But that just never seems to happen for this team.

This time last year, we were excited about the fact that Charlie Morton had turned the corner from terrible to effective and were counting on him to win big this year.  Didn't happen.  We were even more excited about the fact that in 2012 we were going to have four outfielders (Cutch, Tabata, Presley, and Marte) so good that none of them could be on the bench as the 4th outfielder (and we were thus going to trade one of them for another good player).  Didn't happen -- so much so that we had to trade for yet another corner outfielder (Snider) and will probably have to acquire another one in the offseason.

I'm not optimistic any more because I've been around for all 20 years, and my optimism has been taken out back and beaten with a stick so cruelly it is on life support!  That doesn't mean I've given up, or that I won't root for them to win every game.  I'm a Pirates fan, and that won't change regardless of results.  But Lucy has pulled the football away one too many times for me to be optimistic that next year or the year after that is "the year".

___________

 

  

Reply | Quote

Posted: 10/02/2012 10:56 AM

Re: What's worse? 



gr1111 wrote: I'll say about the same thing I said last year at this time about next year's team -- I'm very hopeful, but not particularly optimistic.  On their shoestring budget, everything has to go just right -- minor leaguers have to develop, cheap free agents need to overperform, and all of them need to avoid injury.  But that just never seems to happen for this team.

This time last year, we were excited about the fact that Charlie Morton had turned the corner from terrible to effective and were counting on him to win big this year.  Didn't happen.  We were even more excited about the fact that in 2012 we were going to have four outfielders (Cutch, Tabata, Presley, and Marte) so good that none of them could be on the bench as the 4th outfielder (and we were thus going to trade one of them for another good player).  Didn't happen -- so much so that we had to trade for yet another corner outfielder (Snider) and will probably have to acquire another one in the offseason.

I'm not optimistic any more because I've been around for all 20 years, and my optimism has been taken out back and beaten with a stick so cruelly it is on life support!  That doesn't mean I've given up, or that I won't root for them to win every game.  I'm a Pirates fan, and that won't change regardless of results.  But Lucy has pulled the football away one too many times for me to be optimistic that next year or the year after that is "the year".
That's an understandable perspective.

I have the opposite feeling toward the Steelers.  I have been a diehard football fan my whole life until about 3 years ago.  I got bored.  Everybody got too big, too fast, hit too hard, the rules had to change.  I have been spoiled rotten by the Steelers.  I almost miss the 90's when we were a Quarterback away from multiple championships.  Made it interesting.  Once we got the QB and won a couple (which were great, and I wouldn't trade 'em) I've lost interest.  I still watch, but I don't really follow.  The game is so different.  It's a have's and have not's game, more so than baseball.  The days where Mark Rypien can win a championship are gone.  It's not the team game it was.  If MLB wouldn't kick the fanbase in the balls at every turn, they could make up the ground.  I'm convinced Bud Selig is the Anti-Christ.

Last edited 10/02/2012 10:58 AM by BAMSTEELERFAN

Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/02/2012 12:24 PM

RE: What's worse? 



katoy2j wrote: How can you not be optimistic about the Pirates direction though? Go and read nearly every thread the last month and you would swear this team lost 110 games this year. You know what people were saying when the Pirates lost 100 plus games in 2010? That they just wanted a competitive team one that had a chance to win and what not. This years team is one that will finish between 78-80 wins. It has it's top 2 prospects on track to make the team next year that will join a core of players that range in the ages of 24-27. It has no bad long term contracts and the nearest core player is 3 years away from free agency.

This 20 year streak means nothing to me. If we won 82 games or 80 it's irrelevant for me. What does not having a losing season accomplish? Do you think free agents will be lining up to sign with us if we won 82 games? It comes down to money first and foremost but I seriously doubt those extra couple of wins will tilt the decision in either direction. Agents and players are smart. They can see which teams look like they will step forward. The Nationals finished with an 80-81 record. Edwin Jackson chose them over the Pirates as they had Harper ready to step through next year. If a free agent has a choice between Pittsburgh and the Mets or Mariners, most players would pick the Pirates.
The Pirates winning percentage is .307 over their last 52 games.  That's a pace to lose 112 games.  When the Pirates finished 80-82 in 1973 no one cared about not finishing .500. 

The Pirates have shattered baseball and the 4 major sports record by 4 whole years and counting:

The NBA's Kansas City/Sacramento Kings and the NHL's Vancouver Canucks each lost for 15 consecutive years, the Kings from 1983-98 and the Canucks from 1976-91. The NFL's Tampa Bay Buccaneers finished below .500 for 14 consecutive seasons from 1983-96.

The Philadelphia Phillies held the previous Major League Baseball record with 16 losing seasons in a row from 1933-48. The Baltimore Orioles broke their 14-year streak of consecutive losing seasons this year and are competing for a playoff spot.



Read more: http://www.post-gazette.com/stories/sports/pirates /a-look-at-the-pirates-20-years-of-futility-655651 /#ixzz28AgFdt3C
Reply | Quote

Posted: 10/02/2012 1:07 PM

Re: What's worse? 


This is a pretty accurate representation of how I feel, except I do think I'm a little more "cautiously" optimistic.  I like what's going on in the minors talent-wise, but a little nervous about the teaching of fundamentals. I think we've got a few young guys in the bigs ready to improve again next year, but part of me wonders whether it will click with some.

The years of losing, added with the collapses the last two years, make it tough to be overly optimistic, at least for me.  However, maybe when it's all over and I look back at the season, I'll remember that we really did take a step forward and that there are a few more growing pains left. 

Even though I may not be overly optimistic at this particular moment, I'm as excited as I've ever been at the future of the Pirates.  How's that for wishy washy?
gr1111 wrote: I'll say about the same thing I said last year at this time about next year's team -- I'm very hopeful, but not particularly optimistic.  On their shoestring budget, everything has to go just right -- minor leaguers have to develop, cheap free agents need to overperform, and all of them need to avoid injury.  But that just never seems to happen for this team.

This time last year, we were excited about the fact that Charlie Morton had turned the corner from terrible to effective and were counting on him to win big this year.  Didn't happen.  We were even more excited about the fact that in 2012 we were going to have four outfielders (Cutch, Tabata, Presley, and Marte) so good that none of them could be on the bench as the 4th outfielder (and we were thus going to trade one of them for another good player).  Didn't happen -- so much so that we had to trade for yet another corner outfielder (Snider) and will probably have to acquire another one in the offseason.

I'm not optimistic any more because I've been around for all 20 years, and my optimism has been taken out back and beaten with a stick so cruelly it is on life support!  That doesn't mean I've given up, or that I won't root for them to win every game.  I'm a Pirates fan, and that won't change regardless of results.  But Lucy has pulled the football away one too many times for me to be optimistic that next year or the year after that is "the year".
Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/02/2012 1:13 PM

Re: What's worse? 


I have the opposite feeling toward the Steelers. I have been a diehard football fan my whole life until about 3 years ago. I got bored. Everybody got too big, too fast, hit too hard, the rules had to change. I have been spoiled rotten by the Steelers. I almost miss the 90's when we were a Quarterback away from multiple championships. Made it interesting. Once we got the QB and won a couple (which were great, and I wouldn't trade 'em) I've lost interest. I still watch, but I don't really follow. The game is so different. It's a have's and have not's game, more so than baseball. The days where Mark Rypien can win a championship are gone. It's not the team game it was. If MLB wouldn't kick the fanbase in the balls at every turn, they could make up the ground. I'm convinced Bud Selig is the Anti-Christ.


Selig-ula!  tongue


I know we can't veer too far off the baseball path here, but since you mentioned it, BAM, I've had the exact same feeling about football ever since just after the Steelers beat the Cardinals in the Super Bowl.  I asked myself why that was, and it finally occurred to me that I could get exactly the same (if not better) experience playing Tecmo Bowl on my Nintendo set that I did watching The League Formerly Known As The NFL.  Seriously: it's not football anymore.  It's some kind of horrible, frenetic, pinball game or video football game.  Nobody runs the ball anymore except on gimmick plays, everybody throws for leventy-million-thousand-umpteen yards every single game, nobody can play honest defense because the rules are so ridiculously skewed in favor of the offense, the only way to stop even the worst offenses is to strip the ball or intercept it---so nobody tackles anymore, the offensive linemen hold on every single play....it's freaking terrible.  A lousy, boring, overhyped, distorted, form-over-substance product that is light years removed from the game I knew growing up.  Bleeeccchhhh.


PS In the college game, it's even worse.  Everybody runs "the spread".  West Virginia just beat Baylor 70-63.  That's a basketball score, not a football score except maybe once in a generation.  But it's every week now that you see multiple scores like that.  It's so bad that even some of the sports talk shills are complaining.  I don't recall who it was, but I heard two of them last week talking about how the college game had turned into Tecmo Bowl---the exact same comparison I had already come to. So now the college game is just like the pros.  Isn't that special.  Barf, barf, barf, bleeecchhhh.  Honestly, I'm not a fan of football anymore and it used to be that I never missed a Sunday.

Last edited 10/02/2012 1:19 PM by williamjpellas

Reply | Quote

Posted: 10/02/2012 1:48 PM

RE: What's worse? 



Sangue wrote:
 
The Pirates winning percentage is .307 over their last 52 games.  That's a pace to lose 112 games.  When the Pirates finished 80-82 in 1973 no one cared about not finishing .500. 

The Pirates have shattered baseball and the 4 major sports record by 4 whole years and counting:

The NBA's Kansas City/Sacramento Kings and the NHL's Vancouver Canucks each lost for 15 consecutive years, the Kings from 1983-98 and the Canucks from 1976-91. The NFL's Tampa Bay Buccaneers finished below .500 for 14 consecutive seasons from 1983-96.

The Philadelphia Phillies held the previous Major League Baseball record with 16 losing seasons in a row from 1933-48. The Baltimore Orioles broke their 14-year streak of consecutive losing seasons this year and are competing for a playoff spot.



Read more: http://www.post-gazette.com/stories/sports/pirates /a-look-at-the-pirates-20-years-of-futility-655651 /#ixzz28AgFdt3C
Do you think fans of those teams care at all about any of that?  I have lots of friends in Vancouver who have been fans of the team since the 70's.  I have never once heard them complain about a losing streak.  Do you think Philadephia Philles fans when they went to all those playoff games said to themselves this is great but boy if only we hadn't lost all those years in a row.  What percentage of Phillies fans even knew they had the record before the Pirates had it?

I don't go into the season saying I hope the Pirates break the streak.  If they won 80 or 82 I would be just as frustrated.  Nor will I honestly care if the Pirates hold this streak for the rest of eternity once they do break the streak
Reply | Quote

Posted: 10/02/2012 1:50 PM

Re: What's worse? 



williamjpellas wrote: I have the opposite feeling toward the Steelers. I have been a diehard football fan my whole life until about 3 years ago. I got bored. Everybody got too big, too fast, hit too hard, the rules had to change. I have been spoiled rotten by the Steelers. I almost miss the 90's when we were a Quarterback away from multiple championships. Made it interesting. Once we got the QB and won a couple (which were great, and I wouldn't trade 'em) I've lost interest. I still watch, but I don't really follow. The game is so different. It's a have's and have not's game, more so than baseball. The days where Mark Rypien can win a championship are gone. It's not the team game it was. If MLB wouldn't kick the fanbase in the balls at every turn, they could make up the ground. I'm convinced Bud Selig is the Anti-Christ.


Selig-ula!  tongue


I know we can't veer too far off the baseball path here, but since you mentioned it, BAM, I've had the exact same feeling about football ever since just after the Steelers beat the Cardinals in the Super Bowl.  I asked myself why that was, and it finally occurred to me that I could get exactly the same (if not better) experience playing Tecmo Bowl on my Nintendo set that I did watching The League Formerly Known As The NFL.  Seriously: it's not football anymore.  It's some kind of horrible, frenetic, pinball game or video football game.  Nobody runs the ball anymore except on gimmick plays, everybody throws for leventy-million-thousand-umpteen yards every single game, nobody can play honest defense because the rules are so ridiculously skewed in favor of the offense, the only way to stop even the worst offenses is to strip the ball or intercept it---so nobody tackles anymore, the offensive linemen hold on every single play....it's freaking terrible.  A lousy, boring, overhyped, distorted, form-over-substance product that is light years removed from the game I knew growing up.  Bleeeccchhhh.


PS In the college game, it's even worse.  Everybody runs "the spread".  West Virginia just beat Baylor 70-63.  That's a basketball score, not a football score except maybe once in a generation.  But it's every week now that you see multiple scores like that.  It's so bad that even some of the sports talk shills are complaining.  I don't recall who it was, but I heard two of them last week talking about how the college game had turned into Tecmo Bowl---the exact same comparison I had already come to. So now the college game is just like the pros.  Isn't that special.  Barf, barf, barf, bleeecchhhh.  Honestly, I'm not a fan of football anymore and it used to be that I never missed a Sunday.
Not to deviate further, but I've been working in Morgantown for the past month or so and it is amazing to me how much the University's football program means to this area.  Puts Penn State's issues in perspective.
Reply | Quote

Posted: 10/02/2012 2:10 PM

RE: What's worse? 


Both stink equally bad. Anything short of the playoffs is a disappointment. I'm not going watch mediocrity and call it good.
Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/02/2012 2:59 PM

RE: What's worse? 



katoy2j wrote: No offense but this board is full of pessimism and always will be.
Twenty straight losing seasons hardly breeds confidence. Will they win again someday? Of course. Will it be soon? Probably. But to expect people to feel happy about possible future success at this point is silly, or more likely, just looking for an excuse to be argumentative.

Get over yourself, already. I'm tired of the "I'm a better fan than you" crap. blah2
Reply | Quote

Posted: 10/02/2012 3:29 PM

RE: What's worse? 


I'm not better than anyone. I just keep things in perspective. The thread is out there of how many wins we all predicted the Pirates would win at the start of the season. If someone expected 70 wins and the team wins 78 what would be the basis of the team being hopeless?

I just think big picture as I understand mistakes happen in baseball and luck plays a factor in this sport more than any. If the Pirates lost the first two games of the season and then alternated wins and losses the rest of the way through people would of been fine with that season as it was quite evident significant progress was made this season.

You have two 25 year olds who hit 30 homers each. That is a pretty impressive accomplishment. Add in Marte, Cole, Taillon as well as a bunch of other players and then remember this team will need to spend 15 million in trades or free agency just to keep things status quo with likely the only significant player to exit being Joel Hanrahan and it's quite evident to see that the Pirates have a lot to look forward to next season.

People complain about the plan but it is a process. They tore it down and started to rebuild. You saw a 13 game improvement last year, then a 6-8 year improvement the year after that. I don't see any reasons to expect the Pirates to move backwards anytime soon. Well Hurdle is a reason but he won't last past May of this team struggles next year.
Reply | Quote
Reply to TopicPost New Topic
  Page of 2  Next >