Presley Motes (QB, 6'3", 200) from Thatcher.  Ok, so he didn't make the first or second team... but surprised he is not listed in the honorable mention section at least?

http://www.azcentral.com/sports/preps/history/foot ball/all-state-division-five.php

Stats:

Led Thatcher to a 10-2 record
Offense averaged 42 points per game
Threw for 2064 yds, 24 TDs
Rushed for 376 yards, 9 TDs

As a side note he was also the punter/kicker...
15 punts for 510 yards
49 PATs and 3 FGs

Also a pretty good OLB

Just felt like he should have been recognized.

Youtube link:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JIhjY_NhPNA

Probably a great player, but the recognition of that should not come, nor be expected from some simply selected all state team. The recognition of being a good player comes from within, and those you play against.

This can happen when you mix Apples and Oranges.