Free Trial Ad
Why Subscribe?
  • Player/Prospect News
  • Exclusive Insider Info
  • Members-Only Forums
  • Exclusive Videos
  • Subscribe Now!
InboxChat RoomChat Room (0 fans in chatroom)

Re: FAcy and Draft

Avatar

Posted: 2/14/2013 11:48 PM

Re: FAcy and Draft 


Gameface64 wrote:
I don't believe Harbaugh tried to replace Smith until Kaepernick was ripe. And Kaepernick is an anomaly. If we have a Kaerpernick, let me know. So it's irrelevant that Smith was replaced by CK, because we're talking about Smith vs. Weeden.

And one more time, if Smith was so bad, why was there any controversy around Kaepernick replacing him?
Harbaugh tried to replace Smith with a questionably healthy Peyton Manning before the season as well, don't forget.
It's not irrelevant that the coach that helped him play better then he ever had, still actively tried to replace him-and eventually did.
It should tell you something about his talent level relative to other good QBs.

The controversy was because of how it was done. Is that so hard to see?
Their winning games, Smith's managing it up, and he stayed with a completely unproven young guy.

Gameface64 wrote:
Granted he's not Kaepernick, but right now who is? I can't think of a young QB that I'd rather have, although Luck may eventually prove to be even better. And knowing that Kapernick was not considered the top QB in his draft class shows that great QBs can come from nowhere.
^Here's the problem. When did Kaepernick become the best QB in the league? 
Kap is a good young QB-that's all.
Smith is a so-so vet. We need to be looking for a good young QB.
aka: BrownLeader

Last edited 2/14/2013 11:50 PM by JH360

Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 2/15/2013 9:36 PM

Re: FAcy and Draft 



JH360 wrote:
Gameface64 wrote:
I don't believe Harbaugh tried to replace Smith until Kaepernick was ripe. And Kaepernick is an anomaly. If we have a Kaerpernick, let me know. So it's irrelevant that Smith was replaced by CK, because we're talking about Smith vs. Weeden.

And one more time, if Smith was so bad, why was there any controversy around Kaepernick replacing him?
Harbaugh tried to replace Smith with a questionably healthy Peyton Manning before the season as well, don't forget.
It's not irrelevant that the coach that helped him play better then he ever had, still actively tried to replace him-and eventually did.
It should tell you something about his talent level relative to other good QBs.

The controversy was because of how it was done. Is that so hard to see?
Their winning games, Smith's managing it up, and he stayed with a completely unproven young guy.

Gameface64 wrote:
Granted he's not Kaepernick, but right now who is? I can't think of a young QB that I'd rather have, although Luck may eventually prove to be even better. And knowing that Kapernick was not considered the top QB in his draft class shows that great QBs can come from nowhere.
^Here's the problem. When did Kaepernick become the best QB in the league? 
Kap is a good young QB-that's all.
Smith is a so-so vet. We need to be looking for a good young QB.
I see, you're hard to please. When Kaepernicks grow on trees, we'll just pluck one.
>>> Decleater <<<
Reply | Quote