Free Trial Ad
Why Subscribe?
  • Player/Prospect News
  • Exclusive Insider Info
  • Members-Only Forums
  • Exclusive Videos
  • Subscribe Now!
Inbox

Asante Samuel

Posted: 10/15/2012 11:39 AM

Asante Samuel Post Rating (1 vote)


Hey I noticed Asante took one to the house yesterday. How`s that deal worked out since his departure-you cheap penny pinching fools? I know a lot of you will say they didn`t need him, or they would have never signed him for that type of dollar. All I remember was that Asante was guaranteed at least 1, if not 2 pick 6`s a season and was a perfect fit in this so called scheme BB has. They never had to worry about his end. Instead they`ve brought in goon after goon and have only regressed since his departure! BTW whatever happened to Will Allen? This is a perfect example of the type of crap FA`s this clown brings in every season!
Reply | Quote

Posted: 10/15/2012 1:40 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 


Ok - add Samuel's $10M cap hit to the Patriots salary and then take away $10M worth of players from the roster.  Remember though, for every contract you take off, add another $450K because that is the vet minimum and the player you remove has to be replaced.

Go ahead and post what the Patriots roster would look like if they weren't "penny pinching" and gave Samuel what he wanted.  The Patriots have 7 players that have a cap value of $3M or more (Brady, Welker, Mayo, Wilfork, Mankins, Hernandez, and Gostkoski).  I imagine you don't want to touch any of them, so they would have to slice about 5-8 guys off the roster (and replaced by 5-8 minimal salary guys) to make it work.
Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/15/2012 1:41 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 


I'm more and more convinced that the players aren't the whole problem with the secondary. The guys they have simply aren't THIS bad.
Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/15/2012 2:37 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 



Dude you are waaayyy to emotionally invested in a GAME. Yes we are all welcome to our opinions. You in my opinion go way overboard. Settle down. I for one would not mind going 10-6  and fighting it out in the post season to win two superbowls like the giants have done the last two times they beat the patriots in the big game.

What were the patriots records those years and what good did it do them? Exactally my point.  


patbobby wrote:
Hey I noticed Asante took one to the house yesterday. How`s that deal worked out since his departure-you cheap penny pinching fools? I know a lot of you will say they didn`t need him, or they would have never signed him for that type of dollar. All I remember was that Asante was guaranteed at least 1, if not 2 pick 6`s a season and was a perfect fit in this so called scheme BB has. They never had to worry about his end. Instead they`ve brought in goon after goon and have only regressed since his departure! BTW whatever happened to Will Allen? This is a perfect example of the type of crap FA`s this clown brings in every season!







   

         

Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/15/2012 2:57 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 


Patbobby I'm glad you're not running the Patriots. This is the same Asante that on the very next series got torched for a big play that ALLOWED the Raiders to get that touchdown back and tie the game. Yeah that Asante. (somehow you forgot to mention that.) Then was SUDDENLY injured after getting torched. The QB made a bad throw.

Now if Asante was that good why did the Eagles load up on DB's and let him go elsewhere? After all they were the ones who signed Asante away from New England. Did you forget that as well?

This is the same Asante who could not catch an INT that would have given the Patriots a victory over the Giants in the first Superbowl. Yes that Asante. This is the same Asante who can't tackle, plays 10 yards off of the receiver and makes interceptions on bad throws or jumping a route. The same Samuels who could not then and cannot now defend the fade route. No thanks. And while your mentioning interceptions isn't there a member who played for the Patriots last year and this year who lead the NFL in INT's? 

Guess that shows just because you lead the league in a category it still does not make you the answer.

Chance favors the Prepared Mind.

Reply | Quote

Posted: 10/15/2012 8:54 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 


First, I think they could`ve signed him for less. I remember watching the Patriots show on directv that same night and the hosts were wondering why they didn`t make a pitch for AS thinking they could`ve gotten him for less than what he was projected to go for. 

Second, what about all of those goons he`s drafted or brought in via Free Agency since the AS departure. Last I checked not one of those guys have even come close to replacing him and or they were cut, or they`re not in the league anymore. Think about it, butler, those two db`s that were drafted high in 2008, all of those has-been FA`s he`s brought in and have cut; gallery, fananae, will allen, bodden, springs etc., How about all of those TE`s he signed this season? Drafting goons like McCourty and Dowling; those are premium draft choices he`s wasted. Doesn`t all that add up? It just seems like he`s gone through two tiers of young secondary guys in the last 5 years and it keeps regressing.

Yes, maybe I`m a bit emotional, but like most fans on this board I`m frustrated. This guys lives in the past and still thinks he has Bruschi, Vrabel, McGinnest, Seymour, Ted Johnson, Colvin, and Phiefer were he could get away with using players like troy brown and william gay and hank poteat in the secondary.  
stealthdog666 wrote: Ok - add Samuel's $10M cap hit to the Patriots salary and then take away $10M worth of players from the roster.  Remember though, for every contract you take off, add another $450K because that is the vet minimum and the player you remove has to be replaced.

Go ahead and post what the Patriots roster would look like if they weren't "penny pinching" and gave Samuel what he wanted.  The Patriots have 7 players that have a cap value of $3M or more (Brady, Welker, Mayo, Wilfork, Mankins, Hernandez, and Gostkoski).  I imagine you don't want to touch any of them, so they would have to slice about 5-8 guys off the roster (and replaced by 5-8 minimal salary guys) to make it work.
Reply | Quote

Posted: 10/15/2012 8:56 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 


My Gawd, how many years has he been gone??? ... There is NO rewind button, - get over it & move on.
Reply | Quote

Posted: 10/15/2012 9:00 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 


and you think that garbage they have out there is better?
Morpheus11 wrote: Patbobby I'm glad you're not running the Patriots. This is the same Asante that on the very next series got torched for a big play that ALLOWED the Raiders to get that touchdown back and tie the game. Yeah that Asante. (somehow you forgot to mention that.) Then was SUDDENLY injured after getting torched. The QB made a bad throw.

Now if Asante was that good why did the Eagles load up on DB's and let him go elsewhere? After all they were the ones who signed Asante away from New England. Did you forget that as well?

This is the same Asante who could not catch an INT that would have given the Patriots a victory over the Giants in the first Superbowl. Yes that Asante. This is the same Asante who can't tackle, plays 10 yards off of the receiver and makes interceptions on bad throws or jumping a route. The same Samuels who could not then and cannot now defend the fade route. No thanks. And while your mentioning interceptions isn't there a member who played for the Patriots last year and this year who lead the NFL in INT's? 

Guess that shows just because you lead the league in a category it still does not make you the answer.
Reply | Quote

Posted: 10/15/2012 9:06 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 


Yes, I know I need to let it go but I`m just worried they will do the same to Welker and you got to admit BB`s made some really bad moves in that area lately. But your right, I`ll drop it!
Hunter07 wrote: My Gawd, how many years has he been gone??? ... There is NO rewind button, - get over it & move on.
Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/15/2012 9:18 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 


Yeah, and who were the DB's coaches during A$$ante's time? Joel Collier and Mangina (who, while a swine, did a decent job for the Pats). That's a lot better coaching than the current kids are getting.

Anyway ... yeah ... can't turn back time ... but gotta factor everything in.
Reply | Quote
  • DerekLarsson2
  • Five Star General
  • Rating: 2.9/5 this site
  • 1006 posts this site

Posted: 10/16/2012 5:01 PM

Re: Asante Samuel Post Rating (1 vote)




I always liked Asante Samuel.  He had a rare and brilliant talent for jumping routes at just the right time, and picking-off the QB.  He filled the role that Ty Law had performed, and kept one-side of the field pretty well buttoned-down.  He had a few years where he led the NFL in Interceptions, or was right near the top of the list. He was an Impact player.  

They haven't had a CB anywhere near that level ever since. 

I'm always surprised when people here are rooting for the top-talented players to be denied contract renewals/extensions (and to be replaced by what exactly?).  In Football (unlike Baseball), the money isn't even guaranteed to begin with.  The NFL Owners have all the power over contracts, and the players (the actual Stars of the game) get all the injuries, and all the insecurity.

Top performers should be paid top money. And in regards to the Salary-Cap, you have a 53-man roster here and only about 8-10-12 players that are really Elite or High-Impact players.  So it makes sense to be frugal on the lower-tier players, and pay the Impact-players that carry the team what they deserve.

Too often Bill Belichick and Robert/Jonathan Kraft want to nickle-n-dime the Impact players as well, or in the case of Logan Mankins (who they eventually gave-in to and resigned anyway) flip them the finger during the time in which it would very easy to extend their contracts.   They create far, far more problems and risks then they solve.

Right now, we are seeing the whole Wes Welker thing play out.   If they are dumb enough to stiff him too, then we're all done here -- and they will have just squandered away Tom Brady's final few years and the chance at another possible NFL Championship.

As it is, yes...they are very much still feeling the effects of failing to resign Asante Samuel, and have so for the past 6 years now (with the most lousy Secondary in the NFL year-after-year as the result).  This is their main Team deficiency.

You get what you pay for.

People should instead be far more worried about all the money they have wasted away year-after-year-after-year on poor Draft talent and poor free-agent signings in a futile effort to replace Asante Samuel.   That money adds up too, and it is all just wasted money

And even if they had somewhat overpaid Samuel to keep him here, who cares?     It would not have been wasted money as they would've solved a critical, core Team need (which has gone completely unsolved without him).

But the results in the Secondary have been a disaster (which is the proof of the Patriots failed handling of the situation).

Last edited 10/16/2012 5:26 PM by DerekLarsson2

Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/16/2012 5:24 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 


Dowling hasnt even been on the field as much as i would like.Play him at corner and see what he can do.He was a physical CB at virginia.This defensive coaching staff blows.Bring somebody else.BB is so hard headed.I am tired of seeing this crap year after year.Bring former players to coach these guys.
Reply | Quote

Posted: 10/16/2012 5:25 PM

Re: Asante Samuel Post Rating (1 vote)


Derek,

Thank You!

biggrin
DerekLarsson2 wrote:

I always liked Asante Samuel.  He had a rare and brilliant talent for jumping routes at just the right time, and picking-off the QB.  He filled the role that Ty Law had performed, and kept one-side of the field pretty well buttoned-down.  He had a few years where he led the NFL in Interceptions, or was right near the top of the list. He was an Impact player.  

They haven't had a CB anywhere near that level ever since. 

I'm always surprised when people here are rooting for the top-talented players to be denied contract renewals/extensions (and to be replaced by what exactly?).  In Football (unlike Baseball), the money isn't even guaranteed to begin with.  The NFL Owners have all the power over contracts, and the players (the actual Stars of the game) get all the injuries, and all the insecurity.

Top performers should be paid top money. And in regards to the Salary-Cap, you have a 53-man roster here and only about 8-10-12 players that are really Elite or High-Impact players.  So it makes sense to be frugal on the lower-tier players, and pay the Impact-players that carry the team what they deserve.

Too often Bill Belichick and Robert/Jonathan Kraft want to nickle-n-dime the Impact players as well, or in the case of Logan Mankins (who they eventually gave-in to and resigned anyway) flip them the finger during the time in which it would very easy to extend their contracts.   They create far, far more problems and risks then they solve.

Right now, we are seeing the whole Wes Welker thing play out.   If they are dumb enough to stiff him too, then we're all done here -- and they will have just squandered away Tom Brady's final few years and the chance at another possible NFL Championship.

As it is, yes...they are very much still feeling the effects of failing to resign Asante Samuel, and have so for the past 6 years now (with the most lousy Secondary in the NFL year-after-year as the result).  This is their main Team deficiency.

You get what you pay for.

People should instead be far more worried about all the money they have wasted away year-after-year-after-year on poor Draft talent and poor free-agent signings in a futile effort to replace Asante Samuel.   That money adds up too, and it is all just wasted money.  And even if they had somewhat overpaid Samuel to keep him here, who cares? it would not have been wasted money as they would've solved a critical, core Team need (which has gone completely unsolved without him).

But the results in the Secondary have been a disaster (which is the proof of the Patriots failed handling of the situation).

 
Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/16/2012 5:39 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 


Samuel has been goned for years.Let it go!I will always remember his int drop in the superbowl.To me this is all about coaching and scheme.Its time for a change.
Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/16/2012 6:11 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 


Go back to some of the interviews that were done around the time Asante was leaving. He and BB had a very contentious relationship, but even AS admitted that BB's coaching helped him learn to become a Pro Bowler. If he'd started out someplace else, he'd just as likely be out of the league years ago.

One thing I'm 99% sure of is that when BB spends time with a player reviewing film, you see the difference on Sunday. Brady has talked about this, so have a few other players over the years. I really hope BB spends as much time as possible working with the DB's this week because the position coaches ain't getting it done.
Reply | Quote

Posted: 10/16/2012 6:44 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 


AS was one of the VERY few that did anything after leaving the Pats for a bigger check, ... His longevity was most likely due to the fact he never tackeled anyone, might get hurt after all. - WE are talking football - right???
Reply | Quote

Posted: 10/16/2012 7:10 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 


Ok, then have him get in the film room with this current crop then. If that`s what it takes. I`m not buying it, I think this guy has really lost a step-he`s just too arrogant to admit he has not GM skills. 
dokgonzo wrote: Go back to some of the interviews that were done around the time Asante was leaving. He and BB had a very contentious relationship, but even AS admitted that BB's coaching helped him learn to become a Pro Bowler. If he'd started out someplace else, he'd just as likely be out of the league years ago.

One thing I'm 99% sure of is that when BB spends time with a player reviewing film, you see the difference on Sunday. Brady has talked about this, so have a few other players over the years. I really hope BB spends as much time as possible working with the DB's this week because the position coaches ain't getting it done.
Reply | Quote

Posted: 10/16/2012 9:39 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 


What do GM skills have to do with coaching DBs or having a defensive scheme that doesn't work?  There is zero correlation between them.
Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/17/2012 2:31 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 



Hunter07 wrote: AS was one of the VERY few that did anything after leaving the Pats for a bigger check, ... His longevity was most likely due to the fact he never tackeled anyone, might get hurt after all. - WE are talking football - right???
Not to mention he doesn't have to jam receivers. He's a good 10-15 yards away from the line of scrimmage. Helps him on fade routes. What? He can't cover those?  Well at least he is on the field that gotta count for something.

Chance favors the Prepared Mind.

Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/17/2012 2:33 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 


Oh on a serious note I do like Patbobby's passion. Wish the fans at Gillette had some of it, the place may be louder without having to ask for noise.

Chance favors the Prepared Mind.

Reply | Quote

Posted: 10/17/2012 3:59 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 


His poor GM skills raises a question mark regarding his coaching. If he was indeed all that, he would be able to coach-up those clowns he brings in. Not to say he`s a bad coach, and I know his hands are full, but he might not be the madd scientist everyone thinks he is.
stealthdog666 wrote: What do GM skills have to do with coaching DBs or having a defensive scheme that doesn't work?  There is zero correlation between them.
Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/18/2012 2:53 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 


I do not want to start a big flaming war. However in my opinion patbobby is indicitave of a lot of patriots fans. They are flat out spoiled by the pats success. When is the last time the patriots have had a losing season? I am talking in the win lose column.

Yes they did not make the play offs a couple times, Yes they do not win the super bowl every year. I however am okay with them being in the right place to at least attempt it every year. Eventually the winning ways will end they always do for evey team. I remember back in the day i thought i would die before i ever saw the patriots win a super bowl.... they have won three. Do i hope they win more heck yes but if they do not i would be very good with the three they have won.

I guess in conclusion quit being spoiled guys enjoy it while you can.







   

         

Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/18/2012 3:26 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 


I agree that Pats fans are wicked spoiled. That said, the pass defense has sucked cold chowdah for about 3 years.
Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/18/2012 6:55 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 


Those superbowl wins look like 20 years ago.They have gotten there twice and if they could stop somebody in the end they might have had at least had their 4th.The defense has been an issue going back to 2007.It hasnt gotten better and its time someone is held accountable.BB needs to know that already..
Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/18/2012 8:40 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 


The front-7 is much improved from 2 years ago. Spikes, Hightower, Mayo, Ninkovich, Wilfork, Love, Jones - that's a pretty good unit right there. I just can't figure out why they still don't have as good a pass rush as they should.
Reply | Quote

Posted: 10/18/2012 9:09 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 


Have to agree the line is improved - but they still can't hold onto a lead late in the game. And it's been that way for several years now, - not to mention NOT taking a FG on 4th when "in range" and "going for it". - That's cost them dearly, ...
Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/18/2012 9:56 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 


Normally I'd say that going for the TD instead of the safe FG on 4th was a show of confidence in the D. But in this case I think it's the opposite. I think BB knew he'd need 7 to survive the 4th quarter melt-down. Sadly, the 3 would have been enough.
Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/18/2012 11:08 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 


Sky's the limit for Chandler Jones.When he learns to use his hands and pass rushing moves,he can be a beast.I also like Hightower.I really hope he plays against the Jest lol.I havent seen much from the kid from arkansas that they drafted in the 4th round.I definetly think they can get more of a pass rush on a consistent basis.
Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/18/2012 11:17 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 


Bequette was taken in the 3rd. And, yeah, he seemed to be a pretty disruptive pass-rush in college, kind of expected him to see some action by now.

Jones is going to be a force - it's so clear.

Hightower just amazes me that a guy that freakin' big can also be that freakin' fast. He could be the next Willie-Mac.
Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/19/2012 9:24 AM

Re: Asante Samuel 


Cannot say i disagree. However i do not think it is the talent. I tend to agree with you that it is the promote from within thing. Some f those coaches are way to young to have any true expierience. I really do not think it is the talent.

I think it all comes down to mangina. Think about it after he was screwed over by someone he thought he had agood relationship with and could trust he has not brought anyone into his inner circle and plays everything close to the vest.
dokgonzo wrote: I agree that Pats fans are wicked spoiled. That said, the pass defense has sucked cold chowdah for about 3 years.







   

         

Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/19/2012 12:18 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 


BB needs to get over it already. Pinto and Flounder may make great pro scouts, but they're not cutting it as position coaches.
Reply | Quote

Posted: 10/20/2012 9:58 AM

Re: Asante Samuel 


The safeties are a much bigger problem this year than the CB's are.  And Samuel is no way worth the money he thinks he is.  I live in ATL and have seen every game he's played this year.  That's the first play he made all year.  He's only the second best CB on the team, and he was the third best before Grimes was lost for the year.  Finally, the idea that we "never had to worry about his side" is misguided.  He was good at jumping a few routes and coming up with some plays that made you forget all the times he was being beat.  He was just another part of the Pats system that had CB's playing way off the receivers and giving up first down after first down.
**
**
“I don’t have a response. If I had a response to everything that people said about me or us, then I’d be busy all freaking day responding to things." -- Tom Brady, September 2007
Reply | Quote

Posted: 10/21/2012 9:56 AM

Re: Asante Samuel 



dokgonzo wrote: I'm more and more convinced that the players aren't the whole problem with the secondary. The guys they have simply aren't THIS bad.
Starting to lean your way, Dok. This year, they have turned into end-zone ushers, going backwards instead of getting better.
As a fan I am starting to sour on King Bill Belichick. He hires and fires coaches. He IS responsible.(sp)

Reply | Quote

Posted: 10/21/2012 9:56 AM

Re: Asante Samuel 



dokgonzo wrote: I'm more and more convinced that the players aren't the whole problem with the secondary. The guys they have simply aren't THIS bad.
Starting to lean your way, Dok. This year, they have turned into end-zone ushers, going backwards instead of getting better.
As a fan I am starting to sour on King Bill Belichick. He hires and fires coaches. He IS responsible.(sp)

Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/22/2012 1:39 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 



dokgonzo wrote: I agree that Pats fans are wicked spoiled. That said, the pass defense has sucked cold chowdah for about 3 years.
You just gave cold chowdah a bad name.

Chance favors the Prepared Mind.

Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/22/2012 2:49 PM

Re: Asante Samuel 


The only way this team seems to be able to prevent completions is by getting to the QB. So I think it's time BB rolled out the 4-5-2 defense and blitz 9 guys on every passing down, and let the 2 DB's run around in circles waving their arms.
Reply | Quote
Avatar

Posted: 10/23/2012 11:18 AM

Re: Asante Samuel 



dokgonzo wrote: The only way this team seems to be able to prevent completions is by getting to the QB. So I think it's time BB rolled out the 4-5-2 defense and blitz 9 guys on every passing down, and let the 2 DB's run around in circles waving their arms.
They would probably run around in squares if Boyer had to teach them.

Chance favors the Prepared Mind.

Reply | Quote